Monday, January 09, 2006

A Majority That Matters

John Boehner's idea of a plan for leading the House can be found here (.pdf).

It is a 37-page exposition on leadership (which I found very fascinating as a person who is interested in the field of leadership studies) but found it lacking in heft. The last ten pages were really all I needed to see the basic framework of what kind of Majority Leader Boehner would make. What I really wanted to see was more plan of action and less office pep talk.

Bohner's announcement has been called a "Ms. America speech" and this wasn't a very impressive follow-up effort. Jonah Goldberg's questions might have given us more insight in what to really expect:
MISS AMERICA SPEECHES FOR MAJORITY LEADER [Jonah Goldberg]

I like this idea. They should be forced to answer questions like, "If you have one message for the whole world, what would it be?" Or "What would you put in a time capsule?" "If you had to be an animal, what animal would it be and why?"
It's not good when you are being mocked this early in a race by the likes of Jonah...

Coming up with the right strengths and weaknesses of the Republicans in the House is not that difficult...and Bohner demonstrates a clear command of that material. He's definitely talking about the right issues.

He just seems to be wanting to wait for a consensus before committing to action...and that isn't leadership at all.

I expected more.

1/10 Update

George Will is in Boehner's corner though, that has to count for something...

Mark's Remarks


All I have seen here actually makes me think less of Mr. Boehner as a leader. Great sales pitcher and also seems to know how to turn a phrase, but not anything weighty in terms of real plans for leadership. Oh, how I wish Pence had jumped in with both feet to run!